100% you want to go squared. Long term costs go down as you can rotate the tires, which will give you more life. Apex is the way to go for that as they will get you a much better fit and with a spacer up front ( depending on size ) you can go quite wide. There have been some folks with 18x11 and 19x11 wheels for sale, and there was a gentleman with 18x10s some time back. Keep in mind Apex usually has a " Winter Sale, " so you may be able to plan your Christmas present, ha!
Oh I didn't know, christmas is right around the corner ! I think the looks of 18x11 might throw me off as this is almost kind of my daily driver too. But can I really fit 19x11 in the front? I was pretty much set on squared 285/35 tires on 19x10 wheels.